Domino’s Pizza: Much Better Still Gross, by Arthur Tebbel & Chris Toia – Pop Art… and Chris #59
January 19, 2010 Arthur Tebbel & Chris Toia 1 Comment
Recently Domino’s Pizza has launched an aggressive advertising campaign to push our newly redesigned pizza. We have listened to complaints on our 50 year-old pizza recipe and feel we have a new exciting product. The two of you are the loudest jerks when it comes to trashing the pizza in Los Angeles. We think we finally have a product that can make you homesick. Won’t you try our pizza and tell us what you think?
J. Patrick Doyle, President, Domino’s Pizza
Patrick,
We take our pizza very seriously. We made sure that we tested your pizza in as close to a vacuum as possible. We got what we consider to be the best pizza in LA (which is to say we wouldn’t wipe our asses with it in New York) to make sure we weren’t just pizza crazed and so we had a basis of comparison. We think this is as objective an opinion as you can get. Your pizza is pretty completely terrible.
I think the most space in your ads is devoted to your new sauce so we’ll start by talking about that. In the ad people complain that the sauce tastes like ketchup so you add a bunch of new herbs in it. Now it tastes like ketchup that someone knocked the container of oregano and basil over into. The first note upon biting into your pizza is an overwhelming sweet taste. The sauce doesn’t taste like any other pizza sauce; in fact it tastes like nothing else in Italian cooking.
In the commercial your customers are adamant about your crust calling it “like cardboard,” and you’ve come a long way from there. Now it seems like something you would use to give a vampire a garlic sponge bath. Is this what pizza is like in Chicago or something? It’s really a wretched idea. The crust from our control pizza had that slightly charred taste that a good pie from a pizza oven are supposed to have. This pizza is seemingly baked in a magic oven where there is no chance of it being near an actual heat source. If we hadn’t seen the inside of a domino’s and known there was a real oven there we would swear this was made in a microwave.
You also made a big deal about using 100% whole milk cheese along with “a hint of provolone.” Putting aside that provolone is not a traditional pizza ingredient by any means what the fuck were you using before whole milk mozzarella? Was your last cheese coming out of a spray bottle or something? With apologies to Chris Rock you’re supposed to use real mozzarella cheese you crack heads. While this pizza does taste better than old Domino’s all you’ve really succeeded in doing is turning box wine into Two Buck Chuck. Your company probably has economy of scale coming out its ass and could make a real product if you really gave a shit. What this reveals is that you’ve from having total contempt for your audience to only mostly contempt for your audience. Good work. After 50 years of making bad pizza it just occurred to you that you’re terrible at making pizza. Or maybe this reveals something more horrifying and most of this country just enjoys the taste of terrible pizza.

Martha Thomases
January 19, 2010 - 10:34 am
Was there ever a successful marketing campaign based on the premise, “We used to suck ass, but now we don’t! Honest!”
Shane Kelly
January 19, 2010 - 12:19 pm
AT & CT wrote… “Is this what pizza is like in Chicago or something?”
(GASP) Please tell me…PLEASE tell me that you are NOT ripping on pizza from my hometown. Do I gotta start an East Coast vs. Midwest Pizza Gang War?
Vinnie Bartilucci
January 19, 2010 - 12:31 pm
I remember Thom McAn shoes had a campaign in the subways with ads saying “We swear, all these years a guy was dumping all our good shoes over a bridge in Chicago”.
That Thom McAn is no longer an extant chain is probably testament to its success, but it was a funny ad.
The real reason Dominos and all the other pizza factories are successful is they have customers who have no idea where to find a proper pizza place. So them, “good enough” is good enough. And for some people, “fast” is more important than “good” or even “good enough”.
Bear in mind, I don’t eat pizza at all, I’m watching from a position of dispassionate neutrality. Having said that, Papa Johns’ breadsticks are pretty good.
Elayne Riggs
January 19, 2010 - 12:37 pm
I don’t think their point is to make good pizza. I think their point is to make money for Opus Dei:
http://tech.mit.edu/V111/N18/birnby.18o.html
Better Dead Than Red
January 19, 2010 - 1:03 pm
Did Everyone miss me….?
@ Elayne: Just so you know “Tom Monaghan sold Domino’s in 1998 and has subsequently dedicated his time and considerable fortune to Catholic philanthropy and political causes. A champion of the pro-life cause, Monaghan has spent hundreds of millions of dollars on philanthropy and activism, which has garnered both appreciation and criticism.”
Better Dead Than Red
January 19, 2010 - 1:07 pm
Oh yeah, and their pizza STILL sucks
Marc Alan Fishman
January 19, 2010 - 3:10 pm
Dear Art and Chris,
In Chicago, our pizza is like the city itself: Thick, full of toppings, and buttery. Wait a second… that doesn’t make sense.
Truth be told, I don’t like you guys trying to take a pot shot at my city and it’s pizza. Especially if you live in LA. The california pizza kitchen can put a sun dried tomato, and pan seared pea snap up it’s ass. And New York? You think that’s good pizza? I’m sorry, if the first thing you have to do is fold your slice in half, it tells me that you simply don’t want to look at it as you eat it.
I worked for Dominos, and just had a wonderful laughing fit after trying the “new dominos”. I assure you, you are correct. The sauce is the same (made with a paste and 2 whole pitchers of semi-clean tap water!) just with a fistful of old oregano dumped in. And the crust is the same too, but they douse it in the same ass-spread they coat their breadsticks with. Tada!
Seriously, you get what you pay for. And 1 pizza for the price of a whopper with cheese value meal should just about speak for itself.
Martha Thomases
January 19, 2010 - 3:28 pm
@Marc: New York pizza doesn’t have to be folded. Quite the contrary. A nice, brick-over crust should have some crispness to it.
I’ve enjoyed both Chicago-style and New York-style pizzas. I tend to prefer New York, but that’s all it is – a preference.
California pizza, and especially LA pizza, can’t be any good because they are too afraid of carbs, and there aren’t enough Italians.
Reg
January 19, 2010 - 3:36 pm
@ Marc… gotta agree that the best pie I’ve ever tasted was in Chicago during that cold, COLD, week some years back. So much so that I took three from Geno’s back home with me.
John Tebbel
January 19, 2010 - 3:56 pm
Read an interview with Monaghan once wherein he said he was running a delivery company and it just so happened that what America wanted delivered was pizza. Not immoral, amoral.
Dan
January 19, 2010 - 4:25 pm
Back in the early 70’s my buddy went to Eastern Michigan University in Ypsilanti, just outside of Ann Arbor. The original Dominos outlet was around the corner and whenever we were too hammered, we would walk over and pick up a pie from them. It was only in our drunken state that we could stomach this alleged pizza. The pepperoni was curled into little grease cups and the cheese usually slid off the pie. I haven’t tried the ‘new’ Domino’s pizza, having sworn way back then that I would never again have one.
John Tebbel
January 19, 2010 - 6:08 pm
Mmmm, grease cups.
MOTU
January 19, 2010 - 6:35 pm
Better Dead Than Red,
I missed you.
MOTU
January 19, 2010 - 6:43 pm
Shane,
Chicago Pizza over New York Pizza? You must be OUT OF YOUR FUCKING mind! Dude-how the fuck did we become close friends? The next thing you will be telling me is the Cubs are better than the Yankees! That white girls are sexier than Asian girls! That a HOT threesome is between two guys and one girl…WTF and UGH!!!
Chicago Pizza Over New York Pizza??? SOOOO do you also think that Vanilla Ice is better that Jay Z? That The Bay City Rollers are better than The Beatles?? That Adam Ant is better than F R A N K???
IS YOU STUPID?
MOTU
January 19, 2010 - 6:44 pm
Let me be clear I like white girls but C O M E O N!!!
MOTU
January 19, 2010 - 6:46 pm
OK OK, Amy can hang with the Asian checks.
Shane
January 19, 2010 - 7:51 pm
MOTU said: “Chicago Pizza over New York Pizza? You must be OUT OF YOUR FUCKING mind!”
Nope, oh mighty MOTU, I am quite sane, contrary to what your taste buds may tell you. It’s not that I dislike NY Style Pizza, I simply PREFER a Pizza that can be a whole meal, and not an appitizer.
MOTU said: “Dude-how the fuck did we become close friends?”
Simple, I still have those photos of you and Ling Ling the Panda during your “lost weekend” from years ago. (you don’t kid around with your preference for Asian females)
MOTU said: “That white girls are sexier than Asian girls!”
Now you know that I have to invoke the 5th, in case Amy reads this.
MOTU said: “That a HOT threesome is between two guys and one girl”
You didn’t seem to mind last time that we- uh….Please refer back to the response, from the previous reply.
MOTU said: “Vanilla Ice is better that Jay Z? That The Bay City Rollers are better than The Beatles?? That Adam Ant is better than F R A N K???”
Now Michael, you know as well as I do, that NO ONE is better than Frank!
MOTU said: “The next thing you will be telling me is the Cubs are better than the Yankees!”
Mike, above anything else you wrote, I would like to make this ABUNDANTLY clear “I HATE THE CUBS!” if the Cubs played the Yankees in a World Series (god forbid) I would borrow a Yankee cap and cheer them on!
I am a DIE HARD WHITE SOX fan! I root for my team against all others, including your beloved Yank-mees!
P.S. Amy is GREAT with Asian Chicks
MOTU
January 19, 2010 - 8:01 pm
Shane old buddy, old pal…about those photos…
Alan Coil
January 19, 2010 - 8:16 pm
I’ve had Chicago pizza. Doesn’t work for me.
Alan Coil
January 19, 2010 - 8:24 pm
I, too, have eaten at the original Domino’s. Used to work about a mile from it. Best pizza I had in the 70s was from a different Domino’s. Had it two or three weekends every month. Then they got too expensive. Best pizza I ever had was a Godfather’s deep dish in Toledo, Ohio. But that was in the 80s.
Monaghan ruined the Detroit Tigers franchise. And he took all that money he made from selling pizzas and built a $10 million church in Nicaragua or Venezuela.
I won’t say the Cubs are better than the Yankees, but F U C K the Yankees.
Marc Alan Fishman
January 19, 2010 - 9:42 pm
@Martha …. yes. There I agree. A thin crust pie can be heavenly when nice and crisp. But the street pizza in NYC is floppy and greasy. I’ll admit, I eat hand tossed pies far more than “chicago style” because of how heavy they are. But I’d put up Arrenellos in Glenwood over any dive in the NYC… and I know thems fighting words, but, in the war of pizza…
Every body wins.
and MOTU? The Cubs are better than the Sox. We don’t need championships to retain fans… just shitty beer. 🙂
Marc Alan Fishman
January 19, 2010 - 9:42 pm
whoops, Cubs better than the Yankees. My bad. The reason still applies.
MOTU
January 19, 2010 - 11:31 pm
Alan, Alan, Alan…
FUCK the Yankees? Many have tried most have failed.
MOTU
January 19, 2010 - 11:32 pm
and failed and failed and failed…
MOTU
January 19, 2010 - 11:34 pm
BTW- the White Sox are the only team in the HISTORY of the sport to ever get caught cheating.
Shoeless Joe…HA!
MOTU
January 19, 2010 - 11:35 pm
…and failed.
pennie
January 20, 2010 - 6:15 pm
MOTU,
I tried to fuck the Yankees but they never got past first base. Didn’t know the score, couldn’t hit and didn’t have enough balls.
Chris and Art, I laughed my ass. Excellence!