MICHAEL DAVIS WORLD

You can't make this stuff up, so we don't!

Things Ain’t Like They Used to Be, by Martha Thomases – Brilliant Disguise | @MDWorld

June 16, 2012 Martha Thomases 20 Comments

When I was a girl, and my family would visit New York over the Christmas holidays, my dad’s two uncles would usually spend a day with my sister and me, taking us to Chinatown for lunch and maybe to the Museum of Natural History, where the dinosaur bones would scare me.  As we took the bus uptown, we would pass all sorts of construction projects, and my Uncle Aaron would say, “New York should be a pretty nice place once they finish it.”

At the time, I didn’t know that was a joke.  I thought it was something that could happen.

This week, I realized I had made the same mistake in my thinking about politics.  I had thought that a day would come when, somehow, all the arguments would be settled and we would agree.  We’d settle on a solution and do what needed to be done.

As you know, that hasn’t happened.  It won’t.  There’s too much money to be made in discord.  As long as nothing gets done, the people who are rich will stay rich.  The people who aren’t rich will still spend money trying to get rich.  When there are two teams playing against each other, you sell twice as many jerseys.

Which is probably why there hasn’t been more attention to stories like this.  A person I don’t know, with whom I probably disagree about all sorts of stuff, left the Republican party because, in its current state, it refuses to compromise.  It refuses to acknowledge the patriotism — hell, even the humanity — of people with other perspectives.

“But Democrats do it, too!”  objects the peanut gallery.  “Bill Maher (or Jon Stewart, or Rosie O’Donnell) said something nasty about Sarah Palin!”

It’s not the same thing.  The people on the right who say vile things are, quite often, elected officials, not entertainers.  Joe Wilson is an actual member of Congress.  Whatever you think of Bill Maher, he is not employed by the Democrats.  The GOP elects actual Nazis to its party.

While we argue that both sides do it, the joke  is on us.  We’re working like dogs, stressed out about our jobs, terrified we’ll get fired and lose our health insurance.

It’s killing us.  When it doesn’t kill us, it makes us miserable, denying us time with our families and friends.

Tomorrow is Fathers’ Day.  It’s my first Fathers’ Day with no fathers in my immediate household.  There is no amount of money that I wouldn’t pay to have them back.

Which is why I’m not a Republican.

—- 

Media Goddess Martha Thomases acknowledges that there are Republicans who love their Dads, and knows quite a few.  However, she points out that their policies work against having the time to enjoy them.

Previous Post

Next Post

Comments

  1. Whitney
    June 17, 2012 - 1:03 am

    Want to hear something ironic?

    These neo-nazis (lower case on purpose) – newly elected to represent the Republican party that was described in your link – would not be allowed entrance into our club.

    We aren’t crafting public policy and working towards the development of our communities. We sell liquor and play music. That’s it. And we would determine that they are not worthy to be allowed entrance.

    I’ve learned from experience that the best place to stop trouble is outside your front door. Once inside, innocent bystanders can become bloody collateral damage if a barfight breaks out. All political parties would benefit from understanding this.

  2. Martha Thomases
    June 17, 2012 - 6:59 am

    @Whit: That’s why it’s important to keep the camel’s nose from under the tent, no?

  3. Mike Gold
    June 17, 2012 - 9:21 am

    People who self-identify as Nazis have severe psychological problems. Moving aside what the Nazis accomplished and what they stood for… they were losers. Literally. The Third Reich didn’t last one thousand years, it barely lasted a dozen years and it never attained dominance over the world. Far from it, at its biggest.

    Maybe it’s the appeal of great art direction. If art direction won wars, we’d all be goose-stepping today.

    Ayn Rand fans, take note.

  4. Bill Mulligan
    June 17, 2012 - 8:46 pm

    Omigod! A racist was elected to the prestigious Luzerne County Republican Party Committee??????

    Thank God nothing like that could ever happen with the democrats! Well, except for folks like New York City councilman Charles Barron (who may well be on his way to becoming Congressman Barron (D. New York).

    The difference between the two of us is that I would feel silly using an aberration like Barron to make big generalizations about the whole party. Though at least he’s a guy with some genuine power. Luzerne County Republican Party Committee? Wow, I wonder what shenanigans the dog catcher of Bug Tussle, Oklahoma is up to?

    But, in fairness, they DID elect the guy, probably by a landslide…oh, what’s that? He was was elected to the committee with one vote – his own? Wait, what?

    Ah. “Pennsylvania election law allows any registered Republican or Democrat to write in their name to become a member of the County Committee. Smith was elected with only one write-in vote, which he has since acknowledged was his own, said Terry Casey, chairman of the Luzerne County Republican Party.” (http://usnews.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/06/07/12107097-steve-smith-reputed-white-supremacist-causes-stir-by-winning-election-to-pennsylvania-county-gop-seat?lite)

    You know, it’s not that hard to look this stuff up. It’s perfectly absolutely 100% legitimate for you to not be a Republican. No explanation is needed. But if you insist on providing one, I think you could do better and with far more honesty.

  5. Martha Thomases
    June 18, 2012 - 4:41 am

    There is Alan Keyes, Congressman from Florida tot he United States House of Representatives, who said there are more than 80 members of the Communist party on the other side of the aisle.

    And don’t answer back with Alan Grayson. He was rebuked by fellow Dems. Keyes? Not so much.

  6. Mike Gold
    June 18, 2012 - 5:36 am

    Martha, to be fair, Alan Keyes is a fucking lunatic. Well, by current Republican standards, not so much.

    Keep in mind the Republicans can’t tell the difference between a Communist and a Socialist, and they can’t tell the difference between a Socialist and a liberal, and they can’t tell the difference between a liberal and a Democrat. Following that same path, one can assume they similarly cannot tell the difference between a Nazi and a Republican.

  7. Neil C.
    June 18, 2012 - 6:07 am

    And once again, it’s always, “So the GOP does this? Well, the Democrats do that!” And Martha, my dad also used that same quote about New York being a great city once it’s finished.

  8. Bill Mulligan
    June 18, 2012 - 6:56 am

    I would not have suggested the “So the GOP does this? Well, the Democrats do that!” argument if martha had not explicitly made the claim that “It’s not the same thing.” that the bad democrats are mere entertainers, not elected officials. That kind of invites a correction, doesn’t it? Now the goalposts have been moved to “and don;t include non-entertaining elected officials who lost re-election!”

    I would be more impressed by Grayson’s “rebuke” if he had not been renominated. Were it up to the Democratic party he would still be a representative. Indeed, many of the progressive sites fought hard for him. From good old Wikipedia; “Grayson was endorsed by 8th District resident, former Congresswoman Patricia Schroeder (D-CO), who characterized Webster as having “13th-century views” on women’s issues.[76] Former DNC Chair and Vermont governor Howard Dean called Grayson a “healthcare hero.”[77] Grayson received more votes for “progressive hero” from Democracy for America than any other candidate in the country.[78] Moveon.org, in an appeal to its members, termed Grayson “a populist hero who’s never afraid to call out the pernicious corporate influence in Washington.”

    I don;t know how he was able to show his face in public after those stinging rebukes.

    It’s easy to SAY how unfortunate it is that politics is polarized and that it’s foolish and destructive to accuse those whose only “crime” is to have a different political philosophy than oneself as being “traitors”, “un-American”, akin to “terrorists”, “nazis” etc. It’s easy to say and it feels good and makes us feel like we are not the ones lowering the discourse…but to have any teeth one must not ignore it when folks on OUR side engage in exactly the same thing (and if one believe there are no examples of same, one is fooling one’s self.)

    One correction–I felt bad thinking about the last line in my post above–I did not mean to imply (as could reasonably be inferred by a reader) that it was Martha who was less than honest on the Luzerne County Republican Party Committee Crisis. Few of the progressive sites pimpimg the story gave more details than could be fit on a bumper sticker, for reasons that are now clear.

  9. Martha Thomases
    June 18, 2012 - 7:20 am

    I like Alan Grayson. I don’t agree with everything he says (I don’t agree with everything I said yesterday), but I think he fights the good fight. I just wish he were more effective about it.

    And he’s not effective because he is so polarizing.

    I brought him up in anticipation that someone would say he was rude. I thought it was appropriate to point out that he had been denounced by other Democrats. Not all of them, but a whole bunch. Alan Keyes” Not so much.

  10. Bill Mulligan
    June 18, 2012 - 9:46 am

    I think Grayson’s biggest problem last election wasn’t that he was rude, it was that he was caught red handed lying about his opponent and took so long to correct the problem that the story lasted way longer than it should have.

    BTW, who is this Allan Keyes, Congressman from Florida to the United States House of Representatives, you speak of? There is Alan Keyes, perennial losing candidate for office. There is also Allen West who is indeed a congressman from Florida. As I am not a progressive seeking a cheap snarky point by making a mountain out of an innocent molehill of an error I will refrain from the easy “I guess they all look alike to some people” joke.

  11. Martha Thomases
    June 18, 2012 - 12:38 pm

    My bad. I met Allen West.

  12. Mike Gold
    June 18, 2012 - 3:42 pm

    You weren’t far off. West comes off as a Keyes wannabe who’s off his Tourette’s meds. Check him out: the guy’s truly got the gift of gab: http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2012/02/16/417174/allen-west-15-worst-quotes/

    For those who don’t have the time, here’s one quote from the site: In April 2011, West told a conservative women’s conference that liberal women “have been neutering American men and bringing us to the point of this incredible weakness — to let them know that we are not going to have our men become subservient. That’s what we need you to do. Because if you don’t, then the debt will continue to grow…deficits will continue to grow.”

  13. Rene
    June 18, 2012 - 4:22 pm

    Bill –

    One of the main differences between the parties is that Liberal politicians are still afraid to offend the audiences for the “other” side. Witness any Dem politician about to shit in his pants if he thinks he’s said anything that is offensive to hardline Evangelicals.

    On the other hand, Republican politicians aren’t the least bit afraid to say nasty things about gays, feminists, academics, or any of the typical “audicience” for the Democrats.

    Yes, I do think Dems, in general, are far more concilliatory and open to compromise. But I’m not sure that is a good thing for the Dems. I’m a cynical SOB, and I think Republicans have become more intolerant of other views because they discovered that it works to their advantage, politically.

    It’s not that the GOP is evil* because they like to be evil*. They’re evil* because it pays. The Dems are not evil* because they lack the balls, IMO.

    *I use the word “evil” semi-ironically.

  14. Bill Mulligan
    June 18, 2012 - 9:53 pm

    I could list a number of liberal politicians who have claimed that the other side are traitors, un-american, sabotaging the country, nazi-like, “hostage takers”, “whore”, deserving of death, and, not semi-ironically, “evil”. And that’s the politicians, if one goes to the media it’s possible to find journalists willing to openly speculate on whether a republican’s grandchild getting AIDS would be a fitting retribution or hoping for an early death to a conservative Supreme Court member. One can only wonder what they all would say if they got over their inherent conciliatory nature.

  15. Martha Thomases
    June 19, 2012 - 4:37 am

    Talking about journalists is changing the subject. I specifically brought up politicians precisely because they are chosen by their party and elected. Trust me, as a sometimes journalist myself, I know that the hiring process is much different in the media from the polls.

    Also, the thesis of this entire column is that there is a lot of money to be made by keeping the country divided. It seems that, on that at least, we agree.

  16. Bill Mulligan
    June 19, 2012 - 9:23 am

    That we do.

  17. Rene
    June 20, 2012 - 6:32 pm

    Bill –

    The Internet doesn’t translate emotions well, so you might have missed that I was admiring the Republicans and disdaining the Dems in this aspect.

    Yeah, sometimes you gotta be a little intolerant. The Republicans seem far more proud and unashamed about their ideals. The Dems seem worried about not offending anyone.

    I think there is a bit of political strategy in that. The GOP tries to appeal to their base by appearing hardline. The Dems try to avoid scaring the independents and centrists. Maybe the later is more effective in the long term, but I admire the former more.

    The irony is that McCain, and now Romney, aren’t really cut to play the hardline game.

  18. Ellen Tebbel
    October 25, 2012 - 2:38 pm

    All I can do is try hard to be informed and VOTE. A dear friend of mine from League of Women Voters said “We’re lucky,, considering the few who vote, to get the government we get,

  19. Ellen Tebbel
    October 27, 2012 - 10:29 am

    Wish I was in NY in time to see the latest production of THE HEIRESS’.

    I wish I still lived on the “island” and could visit loved ones and the theater.

  20. Ellen Tebbel
    November 3, 2012 - 12:02 am

    TO THE UNDECIDEDS: WHAT IN HELL IS WRONG WITH YOU?

Comments are closed.