The Difference Engine, by Martha Thomases – Brilliant Disguise | @MDWorld
March 22, 2014 Martha Thomases 6 Comments
Israel is nothing like I expected.
Well, mostly. It is warm and beautiful. There are historical ruins thousands of years old.
But …
It can be disorienting to think that everyone around me is Jewish, but see fewer yarmulkas and tfillen than I see in Manhattan. The street signs, the billboards, the menus are in Hebrew, Arabic and, if I’m lucky, English.
I’ve seen some sights, but that’s not why I’m here. My father left a large sum of money in trust, with the income to be distributed to those in need. One of the stipulations was that a percentage go to Jewish charities. I am here with a few other people on the distribution committee to see some of the work we have backed in the past, and some of the groups who might ask for help in the future.
Like a good little leftie, I had reservations about Israeli policies, particularly as they relate to the Arab population. As a Jew, I had a sentimental attachment to the idea of a Jewish homeland. These attitudes conflicted plenty when I was in New York.
Here, they are almost irrelevant. Almost.
I thought the situation would be Jew against Arab. I thought that Israeli Jews opposed a two-state solution,
Not true.
I’ve met many Jews who work with government and non-government agencies who have devoted their lives to making Israel a shared society, with equal opportunities for all. I met Arabs committed yo making life better for their own communities so that their people could be full, responsible citizens of Israel. I met people with much more nuanced opinions about the Palestinians than I’ve heard from anyone in the United States, no matter the religion or political sensibility. Like just about everything, it isn’t that simple.
After a whopping five days here, I have failed to come up with the one precise action that can fix everything. There need to be billions of steps, including some in the wrong direction (to make the proper way more obvious). We need to trust one another, respect one another and love one another. We need to stop worrying about who looks weak, and start worrying about how to make each other stronger.
We need to pay less attention to who did what last year or last century, and think more about who can move us forward together today.
And here’s the most important thing. Eggplant, tahini, hummus– any combination of two of these things will make everything better. All three together and we might see the Messiah return.
Mike Gold
March 22, 2014 - 8:50 am
“All three together and we might see the Messiah return.”
Hmmm… I see the hash traffic remains strong.
Whitney
March 22, 2014 - 7:17 pm
M –
WOW…Springtime in Israel must be even better than in Paris. And I agree about food that can be shared from a communal bowl: Breaking bread and then dipping it with others is sacred.
Shift the tide, Dearest. What could be done if more embraced stewardship rather than rattle sabers of entitlement…? Maybe we would end up with more plowshares to break up hard ground and get a good harvest. Amen?
P.S. to Golden Boy –
What’s ‘hash’? Do you mean ‘hashtag’?
Mike B.risbois
March 22, 2014 - 9:22 pm
The problem with elected government is it leads systematically to partisanship, and partisanship leads to extremism, and extremism leads to rigid policy way out of sync with the reasonable majority of working citizens. In other words, we (and they) end up electing representatives so loyal to their extreme positions that they cannot negotiate, even when the citizens are champing at the bit to negotiate and compromise.
I don’t see how to overcome this pattern — except maybe through art. And by ‘art’ I include television and pop music — and comics and movies and tap dance, of course. Can’t someone create a story that gives common people the headspace to consider compromise, and the courage to demand it from their government representatives?
This column today is exemplary, but I want a full narrative from somebody.
Douglass Abramson
March 23, 2014 - 1:05 am
Come on Whitney, even boring ole suburban me knows what hash is; and it ain’t electronic, unless someone is using an e-cig against the manufactures instructions.
Howard Cruse
March 23, 2014 - 6:52 am
Hmm. The Israeli politicians are not necessarily in sync with the citizenry. Just like in America. That’s encouraging. I think. Or maybe not, since it’s the politicians who have power. I need more anti-confusion meds. Or hash?
Whitney
March 23, 2014 - 11:05 am
Douglass, Son of Abram –
What’s an e-cig…?
#yo_soy_nerd