MICHAEL DAVIS WORLD

You can't make this stuff up, so we don't!

Across the Wide Missouri, by Martha Thomases – Brilliant Disguise | @MDWorld

November 29, 2014 Martha Thomases 12 Comments

93f85f95a554acf03e2b84bc5c65bb54This is going to sound horrible, and I apologize in advance, but on this Thanksgiving holiday, I’m very grateful to be a gray-haired old white lady living in an apartment in Manhattan.  If I was a young black man living in Ferguson, I would feel like I have a target on my back.

I wasn’t on the grand jury, and I haven’t gone through all the evidence, but by not indicting Darren Wilson for the killing of Michael Brown, the justice system has shown itself to be at least indifferent to the killing of unarmed African-American youth.  This is not the way grand juries usually work, so it makes a person question why this case is so different from the 99.9 percent of other cases that make it that far in the legal system.

At best, some of the testimony presented was questionable.  At worst, according to some conspiracy theorists, the prosecutor didn’t put his best working the case.

Please don’t misunderstand me.  I feel a certain amount of empathy and compassion for Officer Wilson.  If I was in his situation, I, too, might have panicked and fired my weapon (if I had one, which I don’t, unless you count my inner bitch).  But here’s the thing.  Police officers are supposed to be trained.  They are not supposed to panic when an unarmed man looks at them, even if he looks at them really, really menacingly.  Even if he walks towards them.  They are only supposed to fire a gun if there is no other choice.

Michael Brown outweighed Officer Wilson, but that isn’t enough to explain Wilson’s reaction. By his own words, Wilson demonstrated that he say Brown as something other than human.

As I write this, a few news media point out that there are some people rioting, and a much larger number of people protesting.  The violent rioters get the screen time, because fire and shooting make more dynamic television than marches and chanting.

The whole situation breaks my heart.  We shoot down black kids like dogs in the street, because we think of them as dogs in the street.  If you read around the Internets a bit, you’ll see all kinds of people insisting that Brown deserved to get shot because he stole a box of cigars.

Funny, I don’t remember the armed guards firing at Winona Ryder when she was caught stealing much more expensive items.

It’s a tragedy for a parent to have to bury a child.  It’s a horror show for our children to feel that they are being hunted for sport.  It’s an invitation to anarchy (and not the fun kind) to have the police act as if they and the public are rival gangs fighting over territory.

Because I cling to the belief that there is always at least a bit of a bright side (because I love the Glad Game in Pollyanna, one of the world’s grimmest movies), I was relieved to find this. Usually, in these situations, one reads that a frightened public has run out and bought every gun in the state.  Maybe they did that, but they also gave money to the local library, so the kids would have a safe place to go.  And maybe read.

Martha Thomases, Media Goddess, wonders if the lack of indictment was announced on Monday so the news crews wouldn’t confuse rioters with Black Friday shoppers.

Previous Post

Next Post

Comments

  1. Mike Gold
    November 29, 2014 - 10:57 am

    The Ferguson Negros rioted after Michael Brown was shot to death. That justifies the shooting. Besides, Brown was a criminal. All suspected Negro criminals deserve to be shot. It’s as American as grits.

    There’s an old saying that a prosecutor can get the grand jury to indict a ham sandwich, a meme started by Tom Wolfe in The Bonfire of the Vanities. Prosecutor Robert McCulloch got exactly the result he was looking for. This will continue to happen as long as people do not know how a grand jury works. It is not a trial. There is no defense. The defendant has no right — or ability — to have his or her lawyer there to cross-examine or introduce evidence. The standard here is probable cause for an indictment, not proof necessary for a conviction. That’s why Tom Wolfe’s comment has become part of our national lexicon.

    But I wonder. I wonder where Darren Wilson and his wife will live. Maybe they’ll move in with George Zimmerman, wherever he’s hiding. After Michael Brown, Trayvon Martin and dozens of other victims of court-approved murder, I am reminded of the spiritual that gave title to James Baldwin: “God gave Noah the rainbow sign, no more water but fire next time.”

  2. Howard Cruse
    November 29, 2014 - 3:51 pm

    Martha’s “inner bitch” is not to be trifled with, folks. A word to the wise.

  3. R. Maheras
    December 1, 2014 - 8:12 am

    There’s no denying there is a “walking while black” problem in the US — where people are stopped by law enforcement officials for no other reason than their skin color.

    That said, from everything I’ve seen, Michael Brown was the wrong guy to rally around to put a spotlight on the issue.

    I lived in two dangerous neighborhoods when I was a young man, and, during my travels, wandered through many more. And despite the fact that I’m white, I know what it’s like living, going to school and working in a black neighborhood.

    While liberals are quick to dismiss that convenience store video of Brown, people like me who learned the hard way saw, and sized up, Brown’s persona in just a few seconds. In short, it was clear he was one of those neighborhood punks who, if you saw down the alley or street as you were walking, you avoided — even if it meant walking a few blocks out of your way.

    And while it’s true Brown did not deserve to die simply for being a bully, if he did, in fact, go for the Wilson’s gun, then any sympathy I may have had for him evaporates.

    As for your comment “We shoot down black kids like dogs in the street,” all I have to say is what do you mean “we”? If you mean US society at large, it certainly does not condone or encourage the shooting of unarmed black youths by cops. The fact that Ferguson has been such a novelty and rallying point for protesters makes it pretty clear that it doesn’t happen frequently.

    As for cops, well, there have been more than 100 “line of duty” deaths of cops so far this year — 30 in which the cop was shot to death. I don’t know the racial makeup of those incidents, and I don’t really care. The bottom line is that being a cop is a thankless, dangerous business.

    One final note: I don’t know the exact percentages, but something like 80 percent of black youths killed every year are killed by other black youths. And the fact that liberals fail to rally around that cold, every-day reality (just like they ignore the plight of my old neighborhoods, black unemployment in general, etc.) is probably the most damning proof of their misguided priorities.

  4. Martha Thomases
    December 1, 2014 - 1:31 pm

    Russ, I would call your attention to this cartoon (http://www.nytimes.com/slideshow/2012/07/08/opinion/sunday/the-strip.html?ref=opinion#1), this op-ed (http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/30/opinion/sunday/nicholas-kristof-when-whites-just-dont-get-it-part-5.html) and then this op-ed (http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/01/opinion/charles-blow-crime-and-punishment.html) to demonstrate both that unarmed black kids get killed by cops a disproportionate amount, and that the media (in this case, the so-called “newspaper of record”) does point out repeatedly that most black victims of crime are killed by other blacks.

    (By the way, most people who are murdered are murdered by members of their own families, or neighbors or friends. So it’s not surprising that black people kill other black people. White people kill other white poeple.)

    That’s not the point.

    Neither is it the point that Michael Brown may or may not have swiped something from a convenience store. By his own testimony, Wilson said he didn’t know about that incident. He saw a black kid walking down the street, and decided that was something that he (Wilson) had to handle. Because a white kid walking in the street is de facto threatening.

    A police officer shouldn’t get killed in the line of duty. Nobody wants that. However, when one applies to be a cop, one knows the risks. Maybe black parents should be given something to sign acknowledging their risks when they take their babies home from the hospital.

    The problem I want to address is that the grand jury acted like a trial jury, and that is entirely inappropriate. That was not their charge.

    But, hey, it’s just another black kid who some might interpret to be a “bully,” and he got what was coming to him.

    (Note: I’m not saying that Russ says he got what was coming to him. Those are things I’ve seen in comments sections and other places. They make me sick.)

  5. R. Maheras
    December 1, 2014 - 2:22 pm

    P.S. — One final note about Ferguson. After all of the fires have died down from the looted and burned-out storefronts, and the carpetbagger agitators who have descended upon the town have left, if history is any indicator, life in that town will suck for the residents — regardless of their skin color — for decades to come.

    On the west side of Chicago, which went up in flames during the summer of 1968, there are still areas where looted and destroyed businesses have never returned, empty lots of burned out and demolished buildings dot the landscape, once decent property values have never recovered, and crime and poverty is the norm.

    That may be the true long-term legacy for Ferguson.

  6. George Haberberger
    December 1, 2014 - 3:42 pm

    I live about 35 miles from Ferguson but that may as well be 350 miles since the violence and unrest is very localized. That is not to imply I live in a well-to-do area. I live in the sticks, on forty acres of woods. There is crime here but I don’t seek out meth so I am largely unaffected by it. Cops aren’t though. And though Darren Wilson wasn’t seeking a confrontation, cops more often than not, encounter it.

    I am late to the thread but I must agree with Russ Maheras’ points. Michael Brown was not someone to make into a rallying figure.

    As far as the McCulloch not wanting to get an indictment from the grand jury; he was not obliged to even send it to the grand jury. He could have dismissed the case outright. The case became so politically charged that sending it to the grand jury was essentially a way to deflect the outrage from him. He knew that the the case could not be proven beyond a reasonable doubt and that he would lose if he prosecuted it. If he had given the grand jury only information to guarantee an indictment he would have had criticism from the pro-Wilson faction for pursuing the case and then criticism from the pro-Brown faction for losing it.

    And McCulloch, like most of the elected officials in St. Louis and St. Louis County, is a Democrat by the way.

  7. George Haberberger
    December 1, 2014 - 8:30 pm

    “He saw a black kid walking down the street, and decided that was something that he (Wilson) had to handle.”

    Really? Couldn’t it also be that Wilson didn’t want two black kids to get hit by a car? They were walking down the middle of the street. Why assume a racist motive?

    According to his testimony Wilson saw two cars have to go around them. From the grand jury testimony: “Hey guys, why don’t you walk on the sidewalk? The first one said, ‘We’re almost to our destination.’ Okay but what’s wrong with the sidewalk? And then that was as they were passing by my window the second subject said, ‘Fuck what you have to say.'”

    Who sounds like a someone who was looking for fight?

  8. R. Maheras
    December 1, 2014 - 10:39 pm

    Martha — You’ve obviously never been suddenly attacked for little or no reason by some punk bully. Based on the video I saw, Brown was a bully. As someone who had to deal with both white and black bullies on many occasions as a youth, they are unpredictable and often fly off the handle with no provocation. Add to the mix the possibility that Brown was also high, and you’ve got a guy who was capable of doing exactly what Wilson said he did.

    I have no sympathy for bullies of any type, regardless of who they are.

  9. Neil C.
    December 2, 2014 - 5:53 am

    I, for one, thank the officer for stopping the Incredible Hulk from rampaging across the country. No matter what kind of ‘thug’ or ‘bully’ he was, he didn’t deserve to be shot as many times as he did.

  10. R. Maheras
    December 2, 2014 - 8:19 am

    Neil — Didn’t deserve to be shot as many times as he was? If someone fears for their life, I know of no “acceptable” number of times one should fire in the split seconds of an altercation to stop a perceived threat. The fact that Wilson fired 12 times at close quarters and only hit Brown six times tells me he was scared shitless and just panic firing.

    Martha — Your cartoon example has problems. First, the 18 black victims depicted in the cartoon were killed over a period of 15 years. Guess how many cops were shot and killed in the line of duty during that same 15-year period? 826. That’s right, 826. Did you know that? I’ll bet you and most of the people ripping at Wilson didn’t. And why is that? Because it’s extraneous information that does not fit the current narrative that cops are evil, militaristic bastards.

    Further, totally left unsaid is how many unarmed white kids were killed by cops in the line of duty during the same period. Is it more? less? Were the number of deaths proportional to the population? Do you know? Does anyone hollering about this incident know?

    One last thing about racial sensitivities and cops. About 10-15 years ago, while my wife and I were at work and the kids were in school, the cops from my town literally kicked in my front door. They said they got a 911 call from inside, but there was no message — just the call. Thinking someone was incapacitated inside, they kicked in the front door. But the only ones at home were our three scared shitless cats. I didn’t sue the city, accuse anyone of malfeasance, and write my congressman. I just fixed the door jamb and moved on. But if I were a black guy who had been stopped previously by the cops just for being black, I just might have thought they targeted me on purpose. It shouldn’t be that way, but, unfortunately, it is.

  11. Martha Thomases
    December 2, 2014 - 8:50 am

    Russ, how many unarmed black people shot by police over a 15 year time is too many?

    Nowhere do I say it is acceptable for police officers to be shot in the line of duty. I don’t believe that (hence, I didn’t say it). But the fact that they are shot by criminals doesn’t mean they should act like criminals. That just gets us to the place where cops and criminals are rival gangs.

    I’ve tried to find examples of unarmed white kids shot by the police. Can’t find any statistics. I would also object to that behavior.

  12. R. Maheras
    December 2, 2014 - 9:23 am

    I think it goes without saying that one dead innocent black youth is too much. But, as I point out, no one who’s making these accusations in the Ferguson incident knows what the comparable stats are for other youths killed in police incidents because it’s frickin’ obvious that they don’t really think it matters. They have a pre-conceived narrative in their heads, and they try and shape reality to fit that narrative.

    I don’t work that way. I ask questions in every case, and see where the facts lead.

    By all appearances here, based on the forensics, Michael Brown was not an innocent black youth. It appears he attacked a cop, and he got shot.

    And for everyone who thinks cops are trigger-happy, that statistic of 826 cops getting shot and killed in the line of duty during the past 15 years should put things into perspective for ANY reasonable person. One second of hesitation on the part of the cop in a volatile situation could mean he/she is going to end up in the morgue.

    Being a cop is a thankless, dangerous job that everyone loves to second guess.

  13. Rene
    December 2, 2014 - 4:11 pm

    When the tragedy with Trayvon Martin happened, I was all ready to write-off Zimmerman as a Neo-Nazi that shot an innocent black child just because he didn’t want no uppity blacks in his street. But facts came to the fore that indicated that the situation was far more complex than that.

    I know better now. I agree that panic and chaos must have played a larger part in what happened in Ferguson than any malice from Wilson’s part.

    However, I do disagree with Russ and George in some respects.

    Racism in contemporary Western societies works largely as an subconscious force. There was an study that showed that referees in basketball games tended to favor players of the same skin color as themselves. I doubt many of those referees are conscious racists.

    And it’s when we take split second decisions in tense situations that the subconscious affects us most. Subconscious racism may cause a cop to act in a harsher way when the suspect is black, just as the referee making a split second decision to call a foul.

    Also, it doesn’t really matter whether Brown is a shining example of a human being. His being shot down while unarmed struck a nerve with a lot of blacks that have faced similar (but much less severe) harassment in the past.

    I don’t know, maybe it would be a good idea if police departments were forced to reflect the ethnic mix of the city they police. A town with 67% of blacks should have 67% of black policemen.

  14. George Haberberger
    December 2, 2014 - 4:51 pm

    “I don’t know, maybe it would be a good idea if police departments were forced to reflect the ethnic mix of the city they police. A town with 67% of blacks should have 67% of black policemen.”

    The problem with that idea is that a black policeman is desired by other departments who want to enhance their diversity, so a black cop in Ferguson can go to another department that pays better.

    Much has been said about the city government being comprised of mostly whites when the population is mostly black. But not only are blacks not on the ballot, the voter turnout in elections is around 12%.

  15. Neil C,
    December 2, 2014 - 7:55 pm

    I repeat, this kid, no matter what, didn’t deserve to die for his crime (which the cop didn’t know about it). If Wilson was as scared as he was, maybe he shouldn’t have been a policeman. Or maybe he was exaggerating because he knew he was wrong.

  16. R. Maheras
    December 3, 2014 - 1:37 pm

    Rene wrote: “A town with 67% of blacks should have 67% of black policemen.”

    I’ll drink to that!

    Neil — Please stop. The kid wasn’t shot and killed because of the convenience store incident. He was shot and killed because he attacked a cop.

    The convenience store video was just a post-incident snapshot of Brown’s true nature, rather than the benign and innocent one many in the media immediately tried to hang on him.

  17. George Haberberger
    December 3, 2014 - 3:25 pm

    “Rene wrote: ‘A town with 67% of blacks should have 67% of black policemen.’
    ’ll drink to that!”

    In his post above Rene said: “I don’t know, maybe it would be a good idea if police departments were forced to reflect the ethnic mix of the city they police.”

    I don’t think so. That sounds a lot like social engineering. What if a town is 100% white and a black man applies for a job as a policeman? He can’t have that job? Isn’t that discrimination?
    Same thing in reverse. A white policeman can’t have a job if hiring him unbalances the carefully constructed racial balance.

    In his post above Rene said: “I don’t know, maybe it would be a good idea if police departments were forced to reflect the ethnic mix of the city they police.”

  18. Rene
    December 3, 2014 - 3:53 pm

    George –

    So, what’s wrong with the idea of social engineering, by itself? Social engineering doesn’t kill people, people kill people. 🙂 The example of the black policeman in a city of 100% white people (would that be the New York City of the FRIENDS TV show?) is a rather extreme and unlikely example.

    I do think the police is an unique case. For instance, other city officials, it wouldn’t matter as much, because we can reasonably trust normal, well-intentioned people to be fair
    to people of other ethnic groups. However, when it comes to life-and-death, violent situations that depend on split-second decisions, THEN subconscious racism can make a difference.

  19. R. Maheras
    December 4, 2014 - 7:52 am

    I don’t have a problem with “social engineering” in some cases. Just as our elected officials in the House of Representatives represent the majority demographic or their (albeit often jury-rigged) districts, consciously making an effort to balance the demographics of the local cops with the areas they are patrolling is smart governing. It doesn’t mean that one closes the door completely on qualified applicants of a certain race or national origin. It just means that if you have two cop candidates with equal qualification, the tie-breaker might be in, say, a Hispanic-heavy district, that one guy speaks fluent Spanish and the other doesn’t.

Comments are closed.