Labor Unions Are Dying, by Q. Reyes – Artistic Warfare #3
December 28, 2008 Q. Reyes 10 Comments
Could Labor Union be a dying breed? I recently attended a Holiday party for SEIU 721 in Los Angeles. SEIU stands for the Service Employees International Union and it’s one of the most powerful labor organizations in the country, and it’s comprised of many county and state employees.
I didn’t have a problem with their Holiday celebrations to include much needed drinking, eating and dancing. I enjoyed that quite nicely, actually; however, I did feel uncomfortable that night asking a Japanese bartender for Kamikazes, but that’s beyond the point. Something was wrong, and I, as the self-proclaimed “examiner of wrongs” decided to get to the bottom of it.
My brain worked, finally, and I understood what felt unusual, as I will attempt to explain here. First, I estimate the average age of the members present to be at about the forty to fifty year-old range. Everything’s good. Nothing’s wrong with growing up in the free-loving sixty’s and seventy’s. It is obvious that there’s a lot of experience there. The key word here is “most”.
The point of evolution and survival is for the older generations to teach the younger generations to take over one day. The older generations are always at a decline, but when the younger generation numbers are diminishing faster than the older, then there’s a problem.
There’s a lot to be said about experience, and you can only earn it through “experiencing,” but there’s a balance that should be reached, as well. Most Labor Unions in this Country don’t have, or have very dismal youth participation. What does this mean? It means that young leaders are not being groomed to take over the leadership.
The experienced majority is shutting down the young minority, and new members are less likely, and less willing to fight for labor rights. Corporate management, meanwhile, is getting younger and more idealistic, and this generational gap in the Labor Unions will be the eventual cause of it’s own demise.
It is unfortunate that experience has a hard time adjusting to new experience, and in an ever-changing political climate and technology-driven work environment, there will be a time where old experience will become a thing of the past, irrelevant and obsolete.
As more and more experienced Union members retire, there are less and less young members ready to take their place. Eventually ALL experienced members will retire or even die, and at that time there will be no one left to continue fighting and maintaining the rights that were so hard earned.
What could be done? First, there needs to be a major youth outreach in the workplaces. New employees and young employees need to value the Union for what its worth.
Currently, a lot of young Union Members feel they deserve the benefits they currently have, when the fact of the matter is that the generation before them fought for those benefits to even exist in the first place. Young members need to understand and recognize that their rights were an uphill battle and they should be grateful to have benefits at all. They must work hard to keep them, just like the previous generation fought hard to get them.
Second, new young leaders need to be selected and trained. The Union’s values, mission, and history must be passed down and understood, while being careful that tradition does not interfere with much needed change.
Next, a merger of the minds must take place and experience and new ideas need to come together and compromise. Both sides, young and old, must reach a point of maintaining fundamental integrity, while at the same time developing and planning for modernized ways of doing business and dealing with management. Whether it’s through updating technology and communications to attaining new and innovative political influence, change needs to come about.
In this day and age it’s not about “strike, strike, strike” anymore. Negotiations have gotten a lot more intricate and sophisticated, and there’s hardly a clear line between winning and losing.
Experienced members need not to be threatened by new young leaders, and, instead, they need to guide them and give them the tools to allow the Union to evolve and maintain it’s leverage.
Being that Unions are still a new concept, as compared to other organizations, there has never been a need for a transition. This is the curse that plagues the Union and the reason they don’t see the forthcoming age-gap catastrophe coming their way. Prompt action is necessary, and without it, Labor Union’s days are numbered.
Management has gotten a lot more astute, sly, slick and slippery, and are more organized and have a lot more resources than the Unions. Unless the Unions can counter with better weapons than management, it is a matter of time until Unions are no longer are functional, and in turn, become a burden in the workplace.
Most thought-capable people know it is not 1980 or 1990 anymore. The world, the government and the economy have changed vastly since then. There is still time for young members to have a chance to learn, become motivated and fight for their rights.
Prior to Labor Unions the work place felt like a forced labor camp. Many have forgotten, many don’t even know the feeling. It would be devastating to be reminded the hard way.
As for SEIU 721’s Holiday party, I love good ‘ole 70’s soul music, so I don’t have a problem with their choice of music for their Holiday party. Everyone knows there’s no limit to how many times you can do the electric slide.
—
Q. Reyes is a Puerto Rican aborigine who enjoys Christmas shopping at his local 7-Eleven. Q. enjoys long walks on the beach, horseback riding, and stealing Wi-Fi Internet from his dumb neighbors. Suckas! Q. is also a creator of the Ceasar and Chuy program on LATV.
Mike Gold
December 28, 2008 - 10:41 am
I’m saying this as a former member of the Industrial Workers of the World (yep, the Wobblies) who later was a member of and paid dues to a chapter of AFTRA that was financially bankrupt and not in any position to do me a lick of good. I believe in unions, and I believe that collective bargaining is one of America’s greatest strengths.
Unions have been increasingly marginalized for decades — look at the way the UAW is taking most of the heat for the Big 3 collapse, and that $73/hr-average-UAW-wage bullshit. UAW didn’t even defend themselves against that, not seriously and not effectively.
The unions have failed to make themselves relevant to the past two generations at the very least. Part of this is their own fault: they allowed themselves to get red-baited after WWII while, at the same time, they refused to clean the substantial mob interests out of the movement. No wonder that Boomers and Gen-Xers didn’t see much relevance.
Under attack for five decades, the unions took the typical liberal attitude of superiority, as if to say “if you can’t see our wisdom, than you just don’t get it, you sorry fuck.” They didn’t think it was necessary to make the case for each successive generation.
Now we’ve got no medical, no pension, no jobs. People will be hired back at a fraction of what it takes to make ends meet, and before long we’ll be finding thumbs in our hot dogs.
Alan Coil
December 28, 2008 - 10:42 am
Excellent, excellent post.
Unions helped make this country the great place it is, yet the right continues to try to find ways to destroy unions. Why do they hate America?
Mike Gold
December 28, 2008 - 1:53 pm
They don’t hate America, Alan. They just love money more. The capitalist right is like Daffy Duck in the newly-discovered money room: they didn’t dig the tunnel, they didn’t build the railcars, but everything inside it is all theirs.
But don’t worry. Some day you might get trickled down on. Some say you already have: it ain’t the guys who own GM and Ford and Chrysler who are losing their houses, taking their kids out of school, and pawning their wedding rings to pay the emergency room bills.
Yeah, you’re right. Class war. DAMN fuckin’ right!!!
Martha Thomases
December 29, 2008 - 6:07 am
I think there is also a shift in the kinds of jobs younger workers are looking for. Being an office drone is not usually a union job, and neither is IT. There used to be a terrific website, netslaves.com, run by the late, lamented Steve Gilliard, that documented the kind of worker exploitation that is still all too popular.
We need newer, more adaptable unions for these kinds of jobs.
John Tebbel
December 29, 2008 - 6:34 am
Most of the union tradesmen in my grandfathers’ generation worked like dogs to get their kids into white collar jobs that are generally not unionized, whatever their other benefits may be. It wasn’t the unions they were against, it was the physical labor in (grandpa One) the engine test room at a Ford factory where they never got the grease off the floor or (grandpa Two) a homebuilding site where rain or shine or snow or sleet the work went on as long as there was light. In both cases they were glad to have moved up from farming and mining.
The white collar ethic is not yet about solidarity and common cause, but faux-exceptionalism and a competition to rule this or that pile of slag.
Alan Coil
December 29, 2008 - 10:15 am
Dirty floors…
I was working in a factory for over 2 years. The company decided to have an open house. They hired a crew to come in with a scarfing machine, one that grinds the top layer off a surface. They scarfed alongside the presses, and that was the first time I discovered that there was wood there. I had assumed that the floor alongside the presses was cement just like the rest of the place. It was so dirty that it was a dull black just like the rest of the area.
M.O.T.U
December 29, 2008 - 10:08 pm
I belong to the AG4MOTU
Miles Vorkosigan
December 29, 2008 - 10:41 pm
You and your Asian girl fetish… I’m quite happy with my Texas elf babe, thank you veddy bloody much, mate.
I’ve never had a union job, although I got close. I worked very briefly for the State of Tennessee, and the only reason I didn’t join the union is because my boss pissed me off and I quit. Two weeks of him was all I could take. Never work for somebody younger and dumber than you.
Miles
Alan Coil
December 30, 2008 - 8:57 am
“Never work for somebody younger and dumber than you.”
In that case, Mike Gold should always be the boss. 😉
Dwight Williams
January 9, 2009 - 8:06 am
Anyone here been watching the dispute between the City of Ottawa and its bus drivers and mechanics in ATU 279 this past month?