Freedom Is Just Another Word, by Mike Gold – Brainiac On Banjo #351 | @MDWorld
December 9, 2013 Mike Gold 6 Comments
The University of Notre Dame joined certain other Christian (and Catholic, depending on your definition of “Christian”) in suing the government – which is us – over Obamacare. They all are saying it interferes with the initial 15 words of the First Amendment: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…”
They may have a point. At least, I can see their point. Obamacare does prohibit religious-based bans on birth control, although it neither forces nor encourages anybody to control births. However, I would argue that even though they are a religious corporation they still aren’t allowed to discriminate against their employees in the name of their own religion.
But if you buy their argument, then there are lots and lots of laws that prohibit the free exercise of religion. To wit:
In order to get your child into public school, you are likely to be compelled to get your child inoculated against various communicable diseases. This must be an annoyance to Jehovah’s Witnesses, Christian Scientists, Scientologists, and conspiracy theorists alike.
There are all sorts of blue laws that prohibit the sale or certain, or all, goods on Sundays. That’s amusing, but let’s say you work Monday through Friday (I’m told that’s actually typical) and you are some sort of Jew or Muslim. If you can’t do all of your shopping after work and you can’t do it on the Christians’ day of rest, you’ve got to do your shopping on your biblical day of rest. Blue laws prohibit the free exercise of their religion.
There are major faiths that operate hospitals where, if a woman is pregnant and there is a complication in that pregnancy and only one of the two is going to survive, the mother loses. That’s that. No vote. You don’t ask her, or her spouse. She’s allowed to die when her death could have been prevented. Fetuses make up our Death Panels. In fact, even if same sex marriage is legal in your state, is the religion-based hospital obligated to let the spouse make decisions that are commonplace in a heterosexual marriage? If not, are we tramping on that religion’s free exercise of religion?
Most of our public government functions begin with some sort of blessing from some sort of religious leader. Alternating between various religions might be a way around this, so if your local city council meeting ever opens with a statement from a Scientologist, a Rastafarian, a Santerian, a Rosicrucian, or an atheist, please let me know.
(Yeah, I know. There’ve been a few such “blessings” allowed from Wiccans. Groovy, but that’s not exactly the same as having a Thuggee start up the band.)
Where does one person’s right to the free exercise of religion end? At the point where somebody else’s free exercise begins? That doesn’t work very well: whereas shopping malls can force businesses to be open on Sundays and sundry religious holidays, the government cannot. And where do we atheists fit in? Why must we be subjected to the extreme inconveniences of other people’s religions?
Is it worthwhile to give up several of your rights in order to work for a religious-based company? In times of high unemployment, well, maybe, but you are degrading yourself to second-class citizenship. In the United States of America, approved religions are exempt from charges of bigotry. You can hire a non-Christian to work in your office, but if he or she doesn’t want to follow the approved Christian dogma, they are out on their ass. Go find work with the heathens.
Or forget about health care.
Mike Gold performs the weekly two-hour Weird Sounds Inside The Gold Mind ass-kicking rock, blues and blather radio show on The Point, www.getthepointradio.com and on iNetRadio, www.iNetRadio.com as part of “Hit Oldies” every Sunday at 7:00 PM Eastern, rebroadcast three times during the week – check www.getthepointradio.com above for times and on-demand streaming information. Gold also joins MDW’s Marc Alan Fishman, Martha Thomases and Michael Davis as a weekly columnist at www.comicmix.com where he pontificates on matters of four-color.
Doug Abramson
December 9, 2013 - 4:26 pm
Come on Mike, blue laws and hospital regulations don’t affect any religion that actually COUNTS. The people who are affected, otherwise known as THOSE people just have to suck it up! Please excuse me; I’m late for a witch burning and I’m booked for a progrom later tonight. I get to break windows and torch buildings this time!
Rene
December 9, 2013 - 4:51 pm
I used to follow the Liberal line, I used to believe only Christians could be intolerant. Now I believe most people are somewhat intolerant, no matter what are their religious convictions. Atheists are not exempt. It’s like Sturgeon’s Law, only applied to people.
Mike, if you happen to have religious ideas that are at odds with the majority, you will come under fire from BOTH Christians and atheists, believe me. Many people who have had near-death experiences can attest to that. Atheist doctors will denounce them as liars or hallucinating maniacs. Christian ones will say it’s the Devil’s doing.
Whatever lies outside of one’s worldview should be derided, denied, attacked, forbidden.
Rick Oliver
December 10, 2013 - 11:46 am
Many school districts allow a religious exemption for vaccinations. Also, I find no compelling reason why free birth control coverage should be mandatory. Pregnancy and STDs should certainly be covered, but birth control is not in itself a health issue. Insurance companies would probably save a whole bunch of money by eliminating many unwanted pregnancies if their customers have easy access to cheap or free birth control; so it’s probably in their best interest to provide this coverage. If you refuse to provide it to your employees, maybe you should end up paying a higher rate. 🙂
Mike Gold
December 10, 2013 - 12:07 pm
I’m totally in favor of free birth control, but for a fairly unpopular reason: ZPG. Actually, we need to see a serious population reduction.
There are too many people on this planet already. We can’t feed them all. We can’t get clean water to them all. We can’t get sanitation to them all. The combined exhalations of 7.13 billion people is destroying the atmosphere. Before long the disease from our out-of-control population growth will rise exponentially. We do not have a shortage of resources, we have far far too many people consuming our resources.
Births outpace deaths 8 to 3. By 2100, the world’s population is projected to be well over 20 billion people. Triple. We won’t have sufficient space for 20 billion. And we’re talking 86 years.
We have a choice. Stop expanding the population, or die a horrible death. The cost of providing free birth control is quite low compared to the cost of continued ludicrous population growth.
Sadly, the religionist hierarchy will never go along with this. Edward G. Robinson died for our sins.
Rene
December 10, 2013 - 7:52 pm
The population will eventually go down, but the rate we are going, society could go down with it.
That’s always the danger of writing down mystical teachings, you crystalize them, and they outpace their context. In the Iron Age, it made sense for people to reproduce as much as possible. Nowadays, it doesn’t.
But, even if you choose to take a less reductionist approach to religion, and say that God ordered men to reproduce like rabbits because He wanted more people to love Him, it doesn’t make a lot of sense, people are less likely to have much love for anything in a depleted world.
Rick Oliver
December 11, 2013 - 11:44 am
I’m all in favor of birth control. I just don’t see a compelling reason for it to be a mandatory element of a health insurance program.